Historic Cape Resorts Hotels in New York & New Jersey

Cape Resorts operates a collection of elegant historic hotels in desirable coastal locations, offering guests authentic experiences in iconic settings. One standout property is Congress Hall in Cape May, New Jersey, which dates to 1816 and is recognized as America’s oldest seaside resort. This storied hotel has welcomed presidential visitors such as Ulysses S. Grant, Franklin Pierce and James Buchanan, and served as the summer White House for President Benjamin Harrison.

guest room

The Pridwin © Cape Resorts

Modern guests at Congress Hall can expect attentive service and a range of amenities, including the Sea Spa, oceanfront cycling routes and poolside attendants. Dining options include the Blue Pig Tavern, and nearby activities include fishing excursions and visits to historic lighthouses that dot the coastline.

Also in Cape May, Beach Plum Inn offers six luxury cottages on a restored 62-acre working farm. Renowned as an agricultural retreat, the estate features activities such as yoga, horseback riding, hiking and birdwatching. Visitors can shop at The Beach Plum Farm Kitchen & Market or savor farm-to-table dinners prepared with fresh poultry, eggs, vegetables and herbs grown on the property.

Beach Plum

© Cape Resorts

In Sag Harbor, New York, Baron’s Cove captures a relaxed seaside atmosphere with features such as wood-burning fireplaces, a broad veranda, a waterfront front porch and a restaurant that highlights the colorful harbor views. The property offers 67 guestrooms, including village rooms, harbor loft suites with balconies, private garden terraces and dog-friendly options. Guests can enjoy a heated saltwater pool, tennis courts, spa services, culinary events, a fitness center, complimentary beach services and nightly live entertainment throughout the summer season.

On Shelter Island, The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages embodies classic Americana. Located on a 10-acre stretch of Crescent Beach and operating since 1927, The Pridwin provides a full-service spa and complimentary water and land activities such as kayaking, stand-up paddleboarding and tennis, making it a peaceful island retreat for families and couples.

restaurant

© Cape Resorts

For Victorian charm in Cape May, The Virginia Hotel offers boutique elegance across 24 rooms. Guests can relax with afternoon coffee, enjoy a daily Continental breakfast and take part in the hotel’s “social sips” hour in the Ebbitt Room bar, all within a setting that celebrates period details and warm hospitality.